Academy
Clinical Research for Transfusion Services in Africa Training-CIRIS 2024
Syria Laperche
The Institut National de la Transfusion Sanguine in Paris, France
Adama Faye
Cheikh Anta Diop University, Senegal
Edward L. Murphy
University of California, San Francisco, USA
Claude Tayou
Yaoundé University Teaching Hospital, Cameroon.
Saliou Diop
Cheikh Anta Diop University, Senegal
Transfusion safety and the prevention of viral infections remain major problems for public health in Africa. Staff training and capacity building enable blood banks and health systems to implement prevention tools, including surveillance, risk factor research, quality control and assessment of risk factors. It allows trainees to develop research projects nationally and internationally, but also to use the knowledge to improve laboratory practices and better manage their blood banks or hospitals.
A clinical research course on prevention of blood-borne viral infections was provided for 12 years (from 2007 to 2018) at the Institut Pasteur in Paris in collaboration with the University of California San Francisco and Vitalant Research Institute (UCSF/VRI) and the National Institute of Blood Transfusion (INTS) in Paris. These activities have also stimulated the research orientation of transfusion medicine and infectious disease professionals in francophone Africa. The best trainees had the opportunity to continue additional training (Murphy & al, 2009, Tagny & al, 2013). However the Paris course was discontinued after 2018 and there was a perceived need to offer the course closer to its African audience and to satisfy the demand for training of more researchers. The first francophone course in Africa was conducted in Cameroon in 2019 with a successful training of 6 international students and 15 local students.
Group photo of participants with certification
The overarching objective of this second course is to build capacity of a new batch in clinical and epidemiological research in the field of transfusion medicine. The main goals of the course were to present the current state of knowledge on the prevention of transfusion-transmissible infections and to train participants to develop and carry out clinical research protocols in the prevention of transfusion transmitted infections (TTI).
The course was hosted by the Faculty of Medicine, Pharmacy and Odontostomatology (FMPOS) of the University of Cheikh Anta Diop in Senegal (UCAD). We chose a hybrid approach including three online lecture sessions from March 29 to April 11, 2024 and an in-person workshop at UCAD April 15-29 2024. The workshop portion included a combination of didactic lectures and workshop sessions during which trainees each wrote their own short clinical research protocols with close mentoring by faculty.
This course was oriented to young professionals wishing to conduct research, including those working in blood transfusion.
The theoretical content included:
1) background information on blood-borne infections;
2) theoretical lectures on the methodology of clinical and epidemiological research; and
3) workshops during which each trainee wrote their own clinical research protocol.
The protocol writing training followed chapter by chapter, a textbook written by Hulley et al. entitled "Designing clinical research" which explains the theoretical bases of clinical research (Hulley & al, 4th edition, 2013). Although it includes elements of epidemiological theory, its approach is mostly practical and "cross-cutting" - which leads from theory to practice.
We enrolled 12 full-time participants from 7 French-speaking countries (Benin, Cameroon, Guinea, Mali, Senegal, Tunisia). The professors came from the USA, France, Cameroon and the UCAD. The course budget included funding for travel and accommodation expenses of the professors and trainees.
With intensive mentoring, each trainee wrote one section of his/her protocol during every afternoon workshop session. The topics of the protocols included:
- Motivators and deterrents to repeat blood donation
- A randomized trial of skin disinfection protocols to reduce the risk of bacterial contamination
- Risks factors for hepatitis C virus infection in prospective donors
- A regional assessment of the sensitivity and specificity of TTI screening algorithms
- Effect of HIV infection on the frequency of blood transfusion in sickle cell disease patients
- Indications for blood transfusion in a neonatal care unit
- Impact of clinical status on the efficacy of platelet concentrate transfusion
Assessment of trainee performance was done on the basis of three factors:
i) quality of the finished protocol (50% of the total mark);
ii) quality of the peer review of their colleague’s protocol (25%);
iii) participation during class discussions (25%).
At the end of the course, 11 over 12 trainees had a finished six page protocol which was successfully peer-reviewed by their colleagues during the final oral examination.
Finally, all participants evaluated the workshops and overall training content. Because of the limited budget, the organizers could not prolonged the course more than 9 days as requested by the participants.
We expect that several of the research protocols developed will be implemented and manuscript submitted for publication. Based on the success of this edition, we hope to continue this course in future years for the benefit of transfusion medicine professionals in the region.
We thank the sponsors of this course: who are namely,
ROCHE France ; Association pour la Recherche en Transfusion (France);
The International Society for Blood Transfusion (The Netherlands);
and we also thank the technical support of The University of California, San Francisco; The Safe Blood for Africa Foundation; The FMPOS, UCAD and The Etablissement Français du Sang, Paris (France).
We also acknowledge our deceased colleagues Dr. Steven Hulley of UCSF who developed the original course from which the current course was developed and Prof. Jean Jacques Lefrere who helped to organize the French language version at Institut Pasteur.
References
1. Murphy EL, McFarland W, Lefrère JJ. Teaching transfusion medicine research methods in the developing world. Transfusion. 2009 Aug; 49(8):1532-4
2. Tagny CT, Murphy EL, Lefrère JJ; Francophone Africa Blood Transfusion Research Network. The Francophone Africa Blood Transfusion Research Network: a five-year report (2007-2012). Transfus Med. 2013 Dec; 23(6):442-4.
3. Hulley SB, Cummings SR, Browner WS, Grady DG, Newman TB. Designing Clinical Research. 4th Edition. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, 2013, 378 pp.